Across the two World Wars, 521,915 American military personnel were killed, making them the deadliest conflicts they had been involved in to date. But how has the memory of the World War losses impacted future American foreign policy and interventions?

Axis powers Germany and Japan have implemented clauses into their constitutions that explicitly prevent their nations from going to war, indicating that the memory of the humanitarian losses from the World Wars is still very prevalent to them. However, while the US hasn’t officially declared war since 1942, post-war memory has not had the same impact on the nation.

Initially, the USA was a very reactionary foreign power when it came to military intervention. This is shown by the fact that until a direct attack on their home soil (in this instance being the bombing of Pearl Harbour), the U.S had not declared war. However, following their victory, the US became engulfed in the Cold War, and its foreign policy became dictated by the Truman Doctrine and their commitment to NATO.

They also adopted what has come to be known as the “Munich Analogy”, which states that appeasing a foreign aggressive power only encourages further aggression. This was coined in the hindsight of Britain and France gave Germany the territory of Sudetenland (modern day Czechia) in 1938 which arguably then emboldened Hitler to start WW2.

We can see the Munich Analogy’s influence over the US throughout the second half of the 20th century, particularly in Korea and Vietnam.

In the Korean war, the US reaction to North Korea’s invasion of its southern neighbour clearly highlights the US’s commitment to the Munich Analogy and the Truman Doctrine following WW2. Their sole focus was preventing aggressive foreign powers from infringing on their sphere of influence. The memory of the humanitarian losses from the World Wars was almost non-existent; soldiers who had just returned from the deadliest wars in history were immediately sent back out onto the battlefield to protect the nation’s interests – a stark contrast from the axis power’s abstinence from further conflict.

Likewise, in Vietnam, the Munich Analogy can once again be used to explain the US’s intervention – they wanted to prevent the spread of communism. However, the public perception that the Vietnam War was a loss on account of the failure to contain the spread of communism and the humanitarian losses (around 60,000 Americans died) arguably shaped American foreign policy for the coming decades and marked a shift away from the Munich Analogy.

While US intervention in the first Gulf War (1991) can certainly be explained with the Munich Analogy with President Bush explicitly saying, “aggression can’t be rewarded”, following Saddam Hussein’s invasion in Kuwait, the reasons for American intervention in foreign territories become much more dubious when we consider other wars. The memory of the World Wars by the 1990s had all but disappeared for America, whereas Japan and Germany still endeavoured to never enter any wars again based off their memory of the wars.

It could be argued recent American interventions in the Middle East have instead used the Munich Analogy as a retroactive justification for economic and political gains. The justification for the Iraq War was that Iraq possessed Weapons of Mass Destruction (WMDs) which hints that the US was simply preventing foreign aggression. However, the claim that Iraq possessed WMDs transpired to be false.

Whatever the reason for the Iraq War, it is clear that the US’s memory of previous wars has been distorted by the successes they’ve had and the power they wield by being the world’s largest military power. The fact war is almost seen as a means to obtain what they want is such a stark contrast not only to the Axis Powers but also to the US’s allies such as Britain and France who have very infrequently entered conflicts following 1945.

Nowhere is the US’s view of war being a tool to get what they want more evident than the current conflict in Iran. The Trump administration is willing to create worldwide economic instability solely with the aim to prevent Iran from developing nuclear weapons.

While this may seem like an application of the Munich Analogy, when we look at Trump’s attempts at regime change in Venezuela and calls for a new president in Ukraine, it could be construed that this is actually an attempt from Trump to instigate regime change in a country the US has long considered hostile.

Thus, it seems the US is once against using foreign intervention as a vessel to further their world political goals. Having a proxy leader in the middle east would be a huge economic benefit for the US with the large oil reserves in the region – a situation very similar to the US’s oil deals with Venezuela following their removal of Maduro in Venezuela.

In the modern day, the US memory of the humanitarian losses in the World Wars seems non-existent. Donald Trump’s comments highlight how there’s very little hesitation when exercising threats of military intervention and attempts to prevent wars by requiring approval from congress are actively bypassed. And this doesn’t seem set to change any time soon.

So, while the populace mourns the losses of the World Wars on the 11th of November and remember those who gave their lives, governments continue to forget and enter into foreign conflicts. Perhaps by making the memory of the World Wars more prominent could set us on the path towards de-escalation but it seems, in the near future at least, the governmental amnesia looks set to continue and thousands will lose their lives in needless conflicts worldwide.

Leave a Reply

Trending

Website by Theo Damaskos